CONFUSION OVER COAL ASH IN KERR LAKE (Still Murky)
Update Story Posted by Jane Porter on The Indy onThu, May 1, 2014 at 4:44 PM
â€œThereâ€™s been a lot of anecdotal reporting about ash in Kerr Lake,â€ Reeder said at an Environmental Review Commission meeting.
He added that the EPA sampled 20 different sites at Kerr Lake and analysis of the sampling did not show the presence of coal ash.
But some of that â€œanecdotal reportingâ€ Reeder spoke about came from Reeder himself.
On April 17, Reeder said in a T.V. interview with Time Warner Cable News that DENR had found trace amounts of coal ash in Kerr Lake.
The network reported that following the interview, a DENR public information officer sent an email contradicting Reederâ€™s statements in the interview.
The following Tuesday, Reeder himself backtracked before the Environmental Review Commission.
â€œPeople have seen grey material in Kerr Lake, people have seen grey water entering Kerr Lake, things like that,â€ Reeder told lawmakers. â€œEverything that has been tested to date that has been taken from Kerr Lake has turned up negative for coal ash.â€
Bridget Whelan, the communications director for the North Carolina Conservation Network, said the issue remains a point of confusion.
â€œDENR either misspoke when they said coal ash was confirmed there or they are deliberating,â€ Whelan said. â€œThe community up there around Kerr Lake is confused and concerned.â€
The lake shares a border with Virginia and that stateâ€™s Department of Environmental Quality’s response is similarly confusing.
â€œIn the days following coal ash spill, coal ash was observed in the lakeâ€™s waters,â€ said Bill Hayden, a public affairs officer with the Department. â€œIt was only observed and not measured. Testing has been done in the past week or so and there has been nothing to show that there is coal ash in the water.â€
“No coal ash IN THE WATER.”
So no coal ash particles are suspended in the water? Is that what this statement means?
What about the LAKE BOTTOM? Is there coal ash settling on the bottom of the lake where various fish feed? Is there evidence of the coal ash contents in any fish or animals or plants taken from anywhere in, on or on the shores of Kerr Lake
Please, everyone: BE SURE TO PARSE AND DEFINE AND QUESTION EVERY WORD AND PHRASE USED BY OFFICIALS. NEVER TAKE ANYTHING AT FACE VALUE.